The screenplay for the 2007 authorized thriller, written by Tony Gilroy, presents a posh narrative exploring themes of company corruption, ethical compromise, and private redemption inside the high-stakes world of company regulation. The story facilities on a “fixer” for a prestigious New York Metropolis regulation agency who turns into entangled in a harmful conspiracy surrounding a class-action lawsuit in opposition to a strong agricultural conglomerate.
This specific work is lauded for its tight plotting, sharp dialogue, and nuanced character growth. It affords a compelling glimpse into the moral dilemmas confronted by authorized professionals working beneath immense stress, and explores the human value of company malfeasance. The Academy Award nomination for Finest Unique Screenplay underscores its essential acclaim and enduring significance within the authorized thriller style. Its exploration of common themes continues to resonate with audiences and offers a framework for discussions about company accountability and particular person morality.
Additional examination will delve into particular features of the narrative construction, character arcs, and thematic resonance, providing a extra detailed appreciation of the work’s complexity and affect. This contains an evaluation of the movie’s essential reception and its lasting affect on the portrayal of authorized and company worlds in cinema.
1. Company Corruption
Company corruption kinds the thematic core of the Michael Clayton screenplay. The narrative exposes the insidious nature of unethical practices inside highly effective organizations and the affect on people caught of their net. This exploration of corruption offers a essential lens by way of which to view the authorized and ethical complexities of the company world.
-
Cowl-ups and Conspiracy
The screenplay depicts a concerted effort by a company to hide damaging info associated to a poisonous product. This cover-up entails a posh net of deceit, intimidation, and unlawful actions, mirroring real-world cases the place firms prioritize revenue over public security. The narrative underscores the lengths to which such entities will go to guard their pursuits, even on the expense of human life and moral ideas. In Michael Clayton, the cover-up turns into a catalyst for the protagonist’s ethical awakening.
-
Ethical Compromises
The movie portrays the compromises people make when working inside a corrupt system. Characters face moral dilemmas, compelled to decide on between loyalty to the company and their very own ethical compass. This theme resonates with real-world eventualities the place people grapple with the stress to evolve to unethical practices, usually on the danger of their careers and private integrity. Clayton’s inner battle embodies this battle, forcing him to confront the results of his actions inside the morally ambiguous panorama of company regulation.
-
Authorized Manipulation
The screenplay showcases the manipulation of authorized processes to serve company pursuits. This contains using intimidation techniques, suppression of proof, and exploitation of authorized loopholes. These actions spotlight the potential for corruption inside the authorized system itself, elevating questions on accountability and justice. The narrative demonstrates how energy and affect can be utilized to subvert the supposed goal of authorized frameworks, creating an atmosphere the place moral boundaries are simply blurred.
-
Penalties and Accountability
Whereas the narrative depicts the pervasive nature of company corruption, it additionally explores the potential for penalties and accountability. The protagonist’s journey represents a problem to the corrupt system, suggesting that people could make a distinction regardless of the overwhelming energy of firms. This theme offers a glimmer of hope inside an in any other case bleak portrayal of company malfeasance, suggesting the potential of justice and reform. The movie’s conclusion emphasizes the significance of holding people and firms chargeable for their actions.
These interconnected aspects of company corruption, woven all through the Michael Clayton screenplay, create a compelling narrative that resonates with up to date considerations about company energy and moral accountability. The movie’s lasting affect stems from its unflinching portrayal of those points, forcing viewers to confront uncomfortable truths in regards to the world we inhabit.
2. Ethical Compromise
Ethical compromise serves as a central theme inside the Michael Clayton screenplay, driving the narrative and shaping character growth. The movie explores the insidious nature of compromise, depicting how people can develop into entangled in morally ambiguous conditions, usually with far-reaching penalties. The narrative emphasizes the pressures people face inside company environments, the place the pursuit of revenue and self-preservation can erode moral boundaries. Clayton, the protagonist, embodies this battle, initially prioritizing his position as a “fixer” over moral concerns. His journey turns into a examine within the gradual erosion of ethical ideas and the troublesome path towards redemption. The movie means that ethical compromise will not be a singular occasion however a course of, usually starting with seemingly small concessions that pave the best way for bigger transgressions. That is exemplified by Clayton’s preliminary involvement in protecting up the U-North company’s wrongdoings, which in the end leads him down a path of accelerating ethical ambiguity.
Actual-world examples of company scandals, such because the Enron and WorldCom debacles, exhibit the devastating affect of ethical compromise inside organizations. These circumstances spotlight how prioritizing short-term beneficial properties over moral conduct can result in monetary wreck, authorized repercussions, and reputational harm. Michael Clayton affords a fictionalized however resonant exploration of comparable themes, reminding viewers of the real-world implications of such compromises. The movie’s exploration of authorized manipulation, cover-ups, and the silencing of whistleblowers displays the techniques usually employed in real-life company scandals. The implications depicted within the movie, together with authorized battles, private betrayals, and even violence, underscore the potential severity of unchecked ethical compromise.
Understanding the dynamics of ethical compromise inside company settings is essential for fostering moral decision-making and selling accountability. Michael Clayton offers a helpful framework for analyzing these advanced points. The movie encourages viewers to think about the potential penalties of their very own actions and the significance of upholding moral ideas, even beneath stress. By exploring the motivations and justifications behind ethical compromise, the narrative affords insights into the psychological and social elements that contribute to unethical habits. The movie’s final message emphasizes the potential of redemption and the significance of particular person company in difficult corrupt techniques. Whereas acknowledging the problem of navigating morally advanced conditions, Michael Clayton suggests that non-public integrity and a dedication to justice can in the end prevail.
3. Authorized Thriller
The “michael clayton film script” firmly establishes itself inside the authorized thriller style, using its conventions to discover themes of company malfeasance, moral dilemmas, and the complexities of the authorized system. The narrative’s suspenseful plot, pushed by authorized maneuvering and ethical compromises, aligns with key traits of the style, making a compelling examination of justice and accountability inside the high-stakes world of company regulation.
-
Suspense and Intrigue
Suspense kinds the spine of the authorized thriller, and this screenplay masterfully makes use of it. The unfolding conspiracy surrounding the U-North company’s cover-up creates a continuing sense of unease and anticipation. The protagonist’s investigation, fraught with hazard and uncertainty, retains the viewers engaged, mirroring the strain present in basic authorized thrillers like The Agency or The Pelican Temporary. The narrative strategically reveals info, heightening the suspense and compelling viewers to unravel the thriller alongside Clayton.
-
Ethical Dilemmas and Moral Compromises
Authorized thrillers usually delve into moral grey areas, and this screenplay isn’t any exception. Clayton’s position as a “fixer” locations him in morally ambiguous conditions, forcing him to confront troublesome decisions. This exploration of ethical compromise provides depth and complexity to the narrative, partaking viewers in a consideration of moral boundaries inside the authorized career. Much like the protagonist in The Verdict, Clayton grapples with the strain between private integrity {and professional} obligations.
-
Authorized Procedures and Processes
The screenplay’s intricate portrayal of authorized procedures and processes provides authenticity and weight to the narrative. The depiction of depositions, courtroom methods, and authorized maneuvering offers perception into the interior workings of the authorized system. This concentrate on authorized particulars distinguishes the authorized thriller from different thriller subgenres, grounding the narrative in a recognizable actuality. The meticulous consideration to authorized processes echoes movies like A Few Good Males, the place authorized arguments and courtroom drama drive the narrative ahead.
-
David vs. Goliath Narrative
The authorized thriller usually encompasses a “David vs. Goliath” narrative, pitting a person in opposition to a strong establishment. On this screenplay, Clayton’s battle in opposition to the immense assets and affect of the U-North company exemplifies this trope. This energy dynamic creates a compelling narrative arc, because the protagonist should overcome important obstacles to reveal the reality and obtain justice. This theme resonates with audiences who respect tales of abnormal people difficult highly effective entities, just like the underdog narrative in Erin Brockovich.
By successfully using these core parts of the authorized thriller style, the “michael clayton film script” delivers a charming narrative that transcends mere leisure. It affords a thought-provoking commentary on the authorized career, company energy, and the enduring battle for justice inside a posh and infrequently morally ambiguous system. The screenplay’s success lies in its capacity to weave these parts right into a cohesive and compelling narrative that resonates with audiences lengthy after the credit roll. Its exploration of those themes inside the framework of a authorized thriller ensures its continued relevance and affect.
4. Character-Pushed Narrative
The “michael clayton film script” exemplifies a character-driven narrative, prioritizing the inner struggles and ethical dilemmas of its protagonist, Michael Clayton, over intricate plot twists or fast-paced motion. This concentrate on character growth permits for a deep exploration of themes similar to ethical compromise, company corruption, and the seek for redemption inside a posh and morally ambiguous world. The narrative’s energy derives from the viewers’s reference to Clayton’s inner journey, making his decisions and their penalties resonate on a private degree.
-
Ethical Ambiguity and Inner Battle
Clayton’s inner struggles with ethical ambiguity kind the crux of the narrative. His preliminary complicity within the U-North company’s cover-up and his gradual awakening to the moral implications of his actions drive the character arc. This inner battle mirrors real-world eventualities the place people grapple with compromising their values for skilled achieve or self-preservation, including a layer of realism and relatability to the narrative. Examples such because the whistleblowers within the tobacco business or the monetary analysts in the course of the 2008 monetary disaster exhibit related inner struggles between private ethics and systemic pressures. In Michael Clayton, this inner battle in the end fuels Clayton’s journey towards redemption and his determination to problem the corrupt system.
-
Transformation and Redemption
Clayton’s character undergoes a big transformation all through the movie. He begins as a morally compromised “fixer,” prepared to bend the foundations for his shoppers, and evolves right into a crusader for justice, risking his personal security to reveal the reality. This arc of redemption resonates with audiences because it explores the potential for private development and alter even within the face of inauspicious circumstances. Actual-life examples of people who’ve uncovered company wrongdoing, usually at nice private value, echo this narrative of transformation and underscore the braveness required to problem highly effective establishments. Clayton’s journey turns into a strong illustration of the human capability for ethical reckoning and the pursuit of justice.
-
Relationships and Betrayal
The character-driven narrative additionally emphasizes the significance of interpersonal relationships in shaping Clayton’s decisions. His interactions with colleagues, shoppers, and adversaries affect his trajectory and contribute to his inner battle. The betrayal of belief, each skilled and private, serves as a catalyst for Clayton’s transformation, underscoring the affect of human connection on ethical decision-making. Examples of company scandals usually reveal advanced webs of relationships and betrayals, mirroring the dynamics depicted within the movie. In Michael Clayton, these relationships serve not merely as plot gadgets however as integral parts of Clayton’s character growth and his final redemption arc.
-
Affect of Systemic Strain
The narrative explores the affect of systemic pressures on particular person morality. The high-stakes company atmosphere wherein Clayton operates exerts a strong affect on his decisions, demonstrating how institutional constructions can contribute to moral compromises. This depiction resonates with real-world eventualities the place people face stress to evolve to unethical practices inside organizations. Examples embrace the stress confronted by workers to fulfill unrealistic gross sales targets or to miss security violations. Within the movie, this systemic stress serves as a essential backdrop for Clayton’s inner struggles and his eventual determination to problem the established order.
By specializing in these aspects of character growth, the “michael clayton film script” creates a compelling and nuanced exploration of human nature inside a morally advanced atmosphere. The movie’s affect derives not simply from its intricate plot however from its capacity to attach with audiences on an emotional degree by way of the protagonist’s journey of self-discovery and redemption. This emphasis on character in the end elevates the authorized thriller style, providing a profound commentary on the human value of company greed and the potential for particular person company in difficult corrupt techniques.
5. Sharp Dialogue
Sharp, concise dialogue contributes considerably to the “michael clayton film script”‘s success. The screenplay makes use of dialogue not merely for exposition however to disclose character, advance the plot, and heighten rigidity. This economical and impactful dialogue, paying homage to basic movie noir, avoids pointless verbiage, counting on subtext and implication to convey which means. The dialogue’s precision creates a way of realism, grounding the advanced authorized and ethical themes inside the characters’ lived experiences. For instance, a seemingly innocuous change between Clayton and a colleague can reveal underlying tensions and energy dynamics inside the regulation agency, including depth to the narrative with out resorting to prolonged exposition. The strategic use of silence additionally performs a vital position, amplifying the unstated tensions and anxieties permeating the narrative. This strategy mirrors real-world authorized settings, the place strategic communication and unstated understandings usually carry important weight.
Particular examples illustrate the dialogue’s effectiveness. Karen Crowder’s rigorously crafted pronouncements throughout depositions reveal her ruthless pragmatism and calculated manipulation of language. Conversely, Arthur Edens’ more and more erratic pronouncements underscore his deteriorating psychological state and rising ethical readability. These contrasting dialogue types serve not solely to distinguish characters but in addition to focus on the conflicting ideologies at play inside the narrative. The screenplay’s avoidance of melodramatic or overly expository dialogue permits the actors’ performances to convey the nuances of character and emotion, enhancing the general affect of the movie. This restrained strategy aligns with the movie’s practical tone, additional immersing the viewers within the high-stakes world of company regulation.
The “michael clayton film script”‘s impactful dialogue serves a number of narrative features. It propels the plot ahead effectively, reveals character motivations and complexities, and creates a pervasive sense of rigidity and unease. This mastery of dialogue elevates the screenplay past commonplace authorized thriller conventions, reworking it right into a character-driven drama with profound thematic resonance. The screenplay’s enduring affect could be partly attributed to its sharp, practical dialogue, which continues to resonate with audiences and encourage evaluation. This facet of the script exemplifies the facility of concise, well-crafted dialogue in enhancing narrative affect and thematic depth.
6. Tony Gilroy’s Writing
Tony Gilroy’s writing kinds the bedrock of the Michael Clayton film script, imbuing it with distinctive traits that contribute considerably to its essential acclaim. His meticulous crafting of dialogue, intricate plotting, and nuanced character growth create a compelling narrative that explores advanced themes of ethical compromise and company corruption. The screenplay’s success hinges on Gilroy’s capacity to weave collectively these parts right into a cohesive and thought-provoking narrative. Trigger and impact are intricately linked inside Gilroy’s writing; the protagonist’s decisions, formed by the pressures of the company world, result in a cascade of penalties that drive the narrative ahead. The tight plotting, devoid of extraneous parts, retains the viewers engaged whereas permitting for a deep exploration of character and theme. This narrative management is clear all through the screenplay, contributing to the movie’s general affect. The “Bourne” sequence, for which Gilroy contributed screenplays, demonstrates an analogous emphasis on tight plotting and character-driven narratives, additional highlighting his distinct writing type.
Gilroy’s dialogue serves as a key element of the “michael clayton film script,” distinguishing it from typical authorized thrillers. The dialogue is sharp, economical, and infrequently imbued with subtext, revealing character motivations and advancing the plot concurrently. This strategy avoids prolonged exposition, permitting the actors’ performances to convey the nuances of emotion and underlying tensions. The courtroom scenes, as an example, depend on exact authorized arguments and pointed exchanges to create dramatic rigidity reasonably than counting on theatrics or emotional outbursts. This stylistic selection aligns with the movie’s general tone of realism and ethical ambiguity, drawing the viewers into the protagonist’s moral dilemmas. Comparisons could be drawn to different authorized dramas like The Verdict or A Few Good Males, the place dialogue performs a vital position in driving the narrative and exploring advanced authorized and ethical points. Nonetheless, Gilroy’s distinct type, characterised by its restraint and subtext, units Michael Clayton aside.
Understanding Gilroy’s contribution to the “michael clayton film script” offers a deeper appreciation for the movie’s inventive advantage and thematic depth. His writing type elevates the narrative past style conventions, making a character-driven authorized thriller that resonates with audiences on each mental and emotional ranges. The screenplay’s success demonstrates the significance of robust writing in shaping a movie’s narrative and thematic affect. This understanding permits for a extra nuanced evaluation of the movie’s strengths and its contribution to the authorized thriller style. Challenges in adapting such a character-driven narrative to the display embrace sustaining the pacing and rigidity whereas permitting for the mandatory exploration of inner battle. Gilroy’s success in navigating these challenges reinforces the screenplay’s significance as a compelling work of cinematic storytelling.
7. Redemption Arc
The “michael clayton film script” hinges on a compelling redemption arc, intricately woven into the narrative material. Michael Clayton’s journey from morally compromised “fixer” to a champion of justice offers the movie’s emotional core. This transformation will not be a sudden epiphany however a gradual course of, pushed by inner battle and exterior pressures. Initially entangled in a company cover-up, Clayton grapples with the moral implications of his actions, dealing with a selection between self-preservation and ethical accountability. The narrative meticulously traces this inner battle, permitting the viewers to witness the gradual erosion of his cynicism and the re-emergence of his conscience. This resonates with basic redemption narratives present in literature and movie, from Shakespeare’s Hamlet to up to date works like Breaking Dangerous, the place characters grapple with ethical dilemmas and in the end select a path of atonement. The cause-and-effect relationship between Clayton’s decisions and their penalties propels the narrative ahead, culminating in his determination to reveal the reality, no matter private value. This act of defiance marks the end result of his redemption arc, demonstrating the human capability for change and the enduring energy of conscience. Actual-world examples of whistleblowers, like Jeffrey Wigand of the tobacco business or Sherron Watkins of Enron, echo this narrative of redemption, highlighting the braveness required to problem highly effective establishments and expose corruption.
Clayton’s redemption arc operates on a number of ranges, impacting not solely his private trajectory but in addition the narrative’s broader themes of company corruption and authorized accountability. His transformation serves as a counterpoint to the pervasive cynicism and ethical compromises depicted inside the company world. By selecting to reveal the reality, he challenges the system’s inherent corruption, providing a glimmer of hope inside an in any other case bleak panorama. This resonates with audiences who yearn for tales of particular person company and the potential of optimistic change inside seemingly intractable techniques. Moreover, Clayton’s redemption arc emphasizes the significance of non-public accountability. Whereas acknowledging the pressures people face inside company environments, the narrative means that ethical company stays a strong power. Clayton’s final determination to prioritize moral ideas over self-interest underscores the potential for particular person motion to problem systemic corruption and impact significant change. This aligns with broader societal discussions about company social accountability and the position of people in holding highly effective establishments accountable.
Understanding the importance of the redemption arc inside the “michael clayton film script” enhances appreciation for its narrative complexity and thematic depth. This arc serves as a strong automobile for exploring themes of ethical compromise, private accountability, and the potential of redemption inside a morally ambiguous world. The challenges of depicting a plausible and impactful redemption arc lie in sustaining a steadiness between character growth and plot development. The screenplay efficiently navigates this problem by seamlessly integrating Clayton’s inner transformation with the exterior occasions of the narrative, making a compelling and in the end satisfying decision. The movie’s enduring affect stems from its exploration of common themes of morality and redemption, making it related past the confines of the authorized thriller style. The screenplay’s success in the end demonstrates the facility of well-crafted narratives to interact audiences on an emotional degree and encourage reflection on advanced moral dilemmas.
Continuously Requested Questions
This part addresses widespread inquiries relating to the Michael Clayton screenplay, providing additional perception into its narrative complexities and thematic significance.
Query 1: What makes the Michael Clayton screenplay stand out amongst authorized thrillers?
The screenplay distinguishes itself by way of its concentrate on character growth, sharp dialogue, and exploration of ethical compromise inside the company authorized world. It prioritizes Clayton’s inner struggles and moral dilemmas over intricate plot twists, providing a nuanced portrayal of a person grappling together with his conscience.
Query 2: How does the screenplay discover the theme of company corruption?
The narrative delves into the insidious nature of company malfeasance, depicting cover-ups, intimidation techniques, and the manipulation of authorized processes. It exposes the lengths to which highly effective organizations will go to guard their pursuits, usually on the expense of moral ideas and public security.
Query 3: What’s the significance of Michael Clayton’s redemption arc?
Clayton’s journey from morally compromised “fixer” to a champion of justice kinds the emotional core of the narrative. His transformation highlights the potential for private development and the significance of particular person company in difficult corrupt techniques. It means that redemption is feasible even inside morally ambiguous environments.
Query 4: How does Tony Gilroy’s writing type contribute to the screenplay’s effectiveness?
Gilroy’s sharp, economical dialogue, intricate plotting, and nuanced character growth create a compelling and thought-provoking narrative. His capacity to convey advanced feelings and underlying tensions by way of subtext and implication elevates the screenplay past typical authorized thriller tropes.
Query 5: What real-world parallels could be drawn from the themes explored within the screenplay?
The themes of company corruption, ethical compromise, and authorized manipulation resonate with quite a few real-world company scandals and moral dilemmas confronted by people inside organizations. The screenplay affords a fictionalized however insightful exploration of those points, prompting reflection on the challenges of sustaining moral integrity within the face of systemic pressures.
Query 6: Why does the Michael Clayton screenplay proceed to resonate with audiences?
The screenplay’s enduring enchantment stems from its exploration of common themes of morality, redemption, and the battle for justice. Its nuanced characters, sharp dialogue, and compelling narrative supply a thought-provoking commentary on the complexities of human nature and the challenges of navigating a morally ambiguous world.
These responses supply a deeper understanding of the screenplay’s complexities and encourage additional exploration of its themes.
Additional evaluation will delve into the essential reception of the movie and its lasting affect on the authorized thriller style.
Key Takeaways from the Michael Clayton Screenplay
The screenplay affords helpful insights for aspiring screenwriters and people within the complexities of authorized and company worlds. The next factors spotlight key takeaways, illustrated with examples from the narrative.
Tip 1: Ethical Complexity Drives Compelling Narratives: Keep away from simplistic portrayals of excellent versus evil. Discover the grey areas of human morality, as demonstrated by Clayton’s inner struggles and the compromises made by varied characters. The narrative’s energy derives from its exploration of moral dilemmas and the results of particular person decisions.
Tip 2: Sharp Dialogue Enhances Character and Plot: Make the most of dialogue strategically, not only for exposition, however to disclose character, advance the plot, and create rigidity. The screenplay’s concise and impactful dialogue serves as a mannequin for environment friendly storytelling. Observe how Karen Crowder’s calculated pronouncements distinction with Arthur Edens’ more and more erratic speech, reflecting their differing motivations and psychological states.
Tip 3: Subtext and Implication Add Depth: Keep away from overly expository dialogue or narration. Belief the viewers to deduce which means from delicate cues and unstated tensions. The screenplay masterfully employs subtext, permitting the actors’ performances and the visible storytelling to convey deeper which means. Observe how Clayton’s silences and delicate facial expressions usually communicate volumes about his inner turmoil.
Tip 4: Floor Advanced Themes in Relatable Human Experiences: Even when coping with large-scale points like company corruption, concentrate on the affect on people. The screenplay successfully connects the bigger themes to Clayton’s private struggles, making the narrative extra relatable and emotionally resonant. Think about how the narrative explores the affect of systemic pressures on particular person morality.
Tip 5: Construction Drives Pacing and Engagement: A well-structured narrative is essential for sustaining viewers engagement. The screenplay’s tight plotting, strategic reveals, and escalating rigidity serve for example of efficient narrative development. Observe how the narrative steadily unfolds, revealing essential info at key moments to maximise affect.
Tip 6: Character Transformation Fuels Narrative Arc: A compelling character arc can present a strong narrative engine. Clayton’s journey from complicity to redemption drives the narrative ahead, offering emotional depth and thematic resonance. Analyze how his decisions and their penalties form his transformation.
By finding out these key parts, aspiring screenwriters can achieve helpful insights into crafting compelling narratives that discover advanced themes and resonate with audiences. The Michael Clayton screenplay offers a strong instance of the right way to mix intricate plotting, nuanced character growth, and sharp dialogue to create a really impactful cinematic expertise.
The next conclusion will summarize the lasting affect and significance of the Michael Clayton screenplay inside the authorized thriller style and past.
Conclusion
Evaluation of the Michael Clayton film script reveals a compelling exploration of ethical compromise, company corruption, and the pursuit of redemption inside the high-stakes world of company regulation. The screenplay’s power lies in its nuanced character growth, sharp, economical dialogue, and complex plotting. Tony Gilroy’s writing elevates the narrative past style conventions, making a character-driven authorized thriller that resonates with audiences on each mental and emotional ranges. The exploration of Clayton’s inner struggles, coupled with the depiction of systemic pressures, offers a thought-provoking commentary on the challenges of sustaining moral integrity within the face of highly effective establishments. The screenplay’s concentrate on the human value of company greed and the potential for particular person company distinguishes it as a big work inside the authorized thriller style.
The Michael Clayton film script serves as a strong reminder of the significance of particular person ethical accountability and the enduring risk of redemption. Its exploration of common themes, mixed with its masterful execution, ensures its continued relevance and affect, prompting reflection on the advanced moral dilemmas confronted by people inside up to date society. The screenplay’s lasting contribution lies in its capacity to interact audiences in a significant dialogue in regards to the challenges of navigating a morally ambiguous world and the enduring energy of conscience.